Re: Utsa Patnaik / GLF famine

[Marc Blecher <Marc.Blecher@oberlin.edu>]

Yep. It's the same way the field treated Carl Riskin for many years. If you
don't like what he says but you can't refute it, just ignore it.

Marc

___________


On 3/2/07 10:40 AM, "Satya Gabriel" <sgabriel@mtholyoke.edu> wrote:

> I've had a great deal of admiration for Bramall's scholarship,
> recommending him to several students working on related theses and/or
> independent studies. Thus, I'm happy to see his work being
> engaged here and will work my way back through the entirety
> of this thread (despite being somewhat frantically engaged in
> making progress on a manuscript).  Nevertheless, I've been disappointed to
> find in the many books I've reviewed, as well as papers refereed, an
> absence of references to Bramall. Most social scientists (and virtually
> all economists) simply refuse to engage his arguments. It is sad testimony
> to the 'science' in social science.
> 
> =========================================================================
> Satya J. Gabriel
> Dept. of Economics       \|/     "Pay no attention to that man
> Mount Holyoke College  ---0---           behind the screen."
> South Hadley, MA 01075   /|\                                   /
>                                                               /
>                                                       |||||  /
> Home Page: www.satya.us                               {@ @} /
> ===================================================oo0=(_)==0oo===========
> 



_______________

Professor Marc Blecher
Department of Politics
Oberlin College
Rice Hall 224
Oberlin, Ohio  44074  USA
Office: 440.775.8493
Home: 440.774.4702
Mobile: 440.864.5039
Fax: 425.930.0507
E-mail: marc.blecher@oberlin.edu
Website: http://www.oberlin.edu/faculty/mblecher/m-blech.html

 . . . . . . . .

London:
2B Bridge Approach
London NW1 8BD
United Kingdom
Home: (+44) (0) (20) 7681.4800
Mobile: (+44) (0) 7905.299644
Fax: (+44) (0)870.128.7503